Staying at a hotel in Shelter Island provides easy access to attractions like Crescent Beach. The area's charm attracts nature lovers and those seeking quality leisure stays.
Sunset Beach is a 4-star property located just 2 miles from the Greenport Antique Carousel. The hotel features 20 well-appointed rooms, each equipped with a balcony and a dressing room. Enjoy meals at the onsite restaurant and partake in yoga classes for a refreshing experience. Shelter Island Heights center can be reached within five minutes' walk. Nature lovers will appreciate close proximity to the scenic Crescent Beach, which is 1.5 miles away.
Located just 1476 feet from the beach, Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach features a free breakfast each morning. The inn comprises 44 rooms equipped with modern comforts, including a seating area and private bathrooms with eco-friendly toiletries. Guests can relax in the onsite garden or explore cultural attractions like Sylvester Manor, located within 1 mile. WiFi access and parking are complimentary.
House On Chase Creek is a charming 4-star bed and breakfast showcasing garden views. Each air-conditioned room includes a private bathroom and features WiFi for guest convenience. Located just 1.5 miles from Greenport Antique Carousel, this accommodation is a short stroll from local parks. Guests can also access bike rentals to explore the scenic surroundings.
Shelter Island House combines elegant design with 4-star accommodations, just a block from Sunset Beach. The property features air-conditioned rooms with various amenities, including options for a kitchen in select accommodations. The onsite restaurant focuses on local ingredients, enhancing the culinary experience. Guests can enjoy the seasonal outdoor pool, relax on the sun terrace, and explore nearby attractions like Historic Haven's House.
West Neck Guesthouse offers a comfortable stay for guests, featuring a garden and free bikes. The 2-star guesthouse includes air-conditioned units with private bathrooms, some offering kitchenettes for added convenience. Located about 25 minutes by foot to Crescent Beach, guests can unwind in the lovely outdoor seating areas. The property is just a short walk to the center of Shelter Island Heights.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
358 US$
Shelter Island Heights is rich in history, rooted in its founding in the late 19th century. This picturesque location showcases charming landscapes, including the serene Crescent Beach and the historic Sylvester Manor, attracting visitors for its unique blend of culture and nature.
With six exceptional options, the hotel scene in Shelter Island Heights is effectively positioned as a convenient base for travelers. Whether seeking family-friendly accommodations or boutique experiences, visitors will find stunning views and modern amenities that enhance their stay.
